US Government Made Painful Mistakes In Torrent-Finder Seizure » Seedbox List | Seedbox Review | Seedbox Hosting | Free Seedbox's

Seedbox List

Home Rules Map Feedback

Search Website

Site Visits
Today Visits: 4979
This Week Visits: 25789
This Month Visits: 58168
This Year Visits: 1422125
All Visits: 15084992
Record: 138189 In 17.03.2012

Referer:

Poll

Best SeedBox Provider
Super-Seed.me.uk
SeedBoxHosting.co.uk
XoHost.co.uk
Savvyseed.net
Bytesized-hosting.com
leasetorrent.com
Santrex.net
xirvik.com
seedunlimited.com

US Government Made Painful Mistakes In Torrent-Finder Seizure

Three weeks ago the US Government seized 82 domains as part of Operation in Our Sites 2. The authorities claimed that the actions were targeted at websites that were involved in the illegal sale and distribution of counterfeit and copyrighted goods. However, the seizure application that was made public today suggests that the seizure of the BitTorrent meta-search engine Torrent-Finder rested on painful mistakes.

The seizure of 82 domain names by The Department of Justice (DOJ) and Homeland Security’s Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) was making headlines across the Internet in November. In particular, the seizure of the BitTorrent meta-search engine Torrent-Finder was seen as a particularly controversial move.


Torrent-Finder’s owner Waleed Gadelkareem was genuinely surprised by the actions of the US authorities and said earlier that he is determined to fight the seizure. He suspected that the authorities had made a mistake and hired a lawyer to help him with the legal proceedings.


Torrent-Finder’s lawyer David Snead called the seizure “a stretch of the law,” and today it became apparent just how far the law was stretched by the authorities. The application for the seizure warrant was just sent to us by Torrent-Finder’s owner and on first reading several painful mistakes stand out.


To start off the affidavit shows that the authorities worked closely with the MPAA, and the movie industry lobby group is cited multiple times to confirm various claims. In addition, a highly disputed MPAA study is used to signify the severity of movie piracy, despite the fact that it was called into doubt by the Government Accountability Office just a few months ago.


The general description of Torrent-Finder and the four music linking sites that were included in the affidavit are not completely accurate either. The sites are described by Homeland Security’s Special Agent Reynolds as being among the most popular of their kind, but in the case of Torrent-Finder.com we can easily list a few dozen BitTorrent sites that have more visitors.


This investigation has identified five linking, cyberlocker or Bit torrent websites that are among the most popular such websites on the internet for distributing illegal copies of movies, television shows, software and music files.


Aside from the fact that describing the site as one of the most popular of its type is a bit misleading, the core issue is whether Torrent-Finder is indeed a site which use is to distribute illegal copies of movies and music.


To make his case, agent Reynolds characterizes Torrent-Finder as a linking site, which generally “collect and catalog links to files on third party sites that contain illegal copies of copyrighted content, including movies, television shows, software and music.” This description doesn’t really seem to apply to Torrent-Finder.com.


Torrent-Finder does not catalog or collect any files, it simply allows people to search several torrent search engines or indexes. Also, these other torrent search engines do not host any copyrighted material either, but only torrent files that may or may not point to copyrighted content.



The message below is posted on the seized sites

Seized Servers


Another claim from Homeland Security’s Special Agent Reynolds is that the news section on the site was another indication that Torrent-Finder was aiding criminal copyright infringement. He describes it as follows:


I was able to view posts by the user “Torrent Finder,” including “Top 10 Most Pirated Movies on BitTorrent,” “Piracy in The Music Industry,” “The First Episode of ‘The The Walking Dead’ Leaks to BitTorrent,” and “Piracy domain seizure bill gains support.”


This is interesting to say the least, because all these articles from the news section are in fact copies from articles that came from TorrentFreak and other sites. Torrent-Finder used our site as a news source and shared the articles with the users of the site.


From reviewing these posts by the user “Torrent Finder,” I learned that the above -referenced postings contained links and information to pirated movies including “Wall Street Never Sleeps,” “The Social Network,” “Red,” and other movies.


This appears to be another painful mistake. Not only have two of the four articles nothing to do with pirated content, the ones that do are news items that do not link to torrent files or any copyrighted files. A screenshot copy of our “Top 10 Most Pirated Movies on BitTorrent” article is nevertheless included as evidence in the affidavit.


Ironically, the “Piracy domain seizure bill gains support” article comes from CNET and covers the COICA law that would grant US authorities the power to seizure domains, in a similar fashion to what they did with Torrent-Finder.



ICE’s affidavit


The seizure application then continues to describe how the Torrent-Finder site works, and the “Downloads of Infringing Content via Torrent-Finder.com” is particularly interesting. Here, Special Agent Reynolds described how the site can be used to download torrent files from external sites.


Although the description itself is fairly accurate, the same section would also apply to every other search engine including Google and Bing. Downloading torrents via Torrent-Finder involves exactly the same steps as downloading torrents via a web search engine, nothing more nothing less.


Another part of the affidavit that stands out is the fact that the proposed seizure has not been carried out properly. According to the affidavit, the authorities should present the warrant to both the registrar (Godaddy) and the registry (Verisign). The registrar would then have to replace the domain name’s technical and administrative contacts with that of the authorities, but this never happened.


Although we’re not legal experts, in our opinion there were enough mistakes made in the affidavit to warrant an appeal against the seizure and get the domain transferred back to the original owner. In order to achieve this, Torrent-Finder’s owner is willing to put up a fight.


“My concern now is to get back my domain. Not because I do business with it, but because it was the first domain I bought and the first idea that I developed. It has been mine since then and I WILL NOT give it away because the USA government is testing a new bill,” Waleed said, referring to the COICA bill that would make such domain seizures standard procedure.


In the coming days Waleed and his lawyer will consider what steps to take next, and we expect that this will not be the last time we report on this unique case.


Article from: TorrentFreak.

16 July 2011 08:26
#1

air jordan shoes

  • Group Name: Guests
  • Date Registered: --
  • ICQ: --
to the New York Times, I am the first to to <i><b><a href=http://www.topbootsforsales.com>UGG boots on sale</a></b></i> to admit that were I not a woman, I would
have been the vice-presidential nominee.The Times reported in 1984 that that <i><b><a href=http://www.topbootsforsales.com>cheap uggs classic tall</a></b></i> that Barbara Bush, wife of then-Vice President George H.W. Bush,
her opinion of vice-presidential candidate Ferraro, called her a a <b><a href=http://www.topbootsforsales.com>cheap uggs classic tall</a></b> a four-million-dollar -- I can't say it, but it rhymes
31 March 2012 18:43
#2

Alohavien

  • Group Name: Guests
  • Date Registered: --
  • ICQ: --
Appreciate your the nicely given information and facts. Regretfull for the offtopic blog nevertheless i just need an individual to share the idea with. I'm actually distraught over the instance I confronted in the office and am simply sitting down here, typing in order to kill time. Want a person to go through my head and offer a responsible judgment. I am a professor of British literature at the university of California state and I faced head on a trouble with one of my students earlier this week. A young man by the name Mike uploaded a term paper for my own course in line with the scarlett letter novel. While I was grading the papers, I just read over the essay and it flowed fantastically. I thought that the composition was incredibly nice and that this well deserved to be allocated a straight A grade. I was just about finished with the grading when all of the sudden it occured to me that I was doing something wrong. The kid was one of the worst learners in my course. How could he create this type of mona lisa. I smelled a thing and questioned them to come see me in my office following school. There was a serious talk and I was able to make the youngster divulge the supplier of the brilliant work. It turned out he obtained an essay on the net online, so it was completed by another person. I researched search engines and located the web-site straight aways (the key phrase I used was Cheap Essays) and so they arise right on the first web page. Now my trouble is how to continue my educational function if there are actually such sites around? Any of my pupils can go and get a term paper. What can I actually do to the kid who got stuck? I am sipping on a alcohol, pondering tough...
31 March 2012 18:43
#3

AlohaTelp

  • Group Name: Guests
  • Date Registered: --
  • ICQ: --
Appreciation for the very well given advice. I'm sorry for the offtopic entry however simply need person to share the idea with. I'm seriously distraught over the case I faced at the workplace and 'm simply seated here, writing in order to kill time. Will need another person to read my thoughts and provide an honest judgment. I'm a lecturer of English literature at the school of Southern california and I touched a difficulty with one of my students a short while ago. A youngster by the name Mack submitted a term paper for my class according to the scarlett letter novel. While I was grading the papers, I just read through the essay and it flowed superbly. I thought that the composition was quite nice and that this well earned to be given a straight A grade. I was pretty much finished with the grading when all of a sudden it occured to me that I was doing something completely wrong. The youngster was among the worst pupils in my course. How could he create such a mona lisa. I smelled something and enquired them to come see me in my business office right after school. We had a severe chat and I managed to make the kid disclose the source of the brilliant work. It proved he purchased an essay online online, so it was completed by somebody else. I explored yahoo and bing and found the web site right aways (the key word I used was Essay Help) and so they show up right on the very first page. Now my trouble is how does someone keep on my academic function if you can find such sites on the market? All of my learners can go and get a term paper. What shall I actually do to the kid who got stuck? I am drinking on a ale, pondering tough...
27 April 2012 03:50
#4

GenaAgew

  • Group Name: Guests
  • Date Registered: --
  • ICQ: --
I am a approved tutor at an national college. One of my school students not too long ago was caught publishing an essay that's obtained off the world wide web. I personally detected the kid working with a computer software termed Turnitin. That thing is often successful for plagiarism reduction. A student sent in a term paper that the software package located as a free essay on the internet geology essay. Naturally We gave the kid an fail grade and required to take the course over. The big dilemma is that at this time there are lots of businesses that present publishing service that are customized. Kids can seek the services of specialist writers to have their homework completed. Is Government intending to fix the problem with custom writing in some way? I think not.

I'm a acknowledged teacher at an us higher education. One of my learners a short time ago was found presenting an essay that has been obtained off the web. I personally found the little one working with a software program termed Turnitin. That thing is often successful for plagiarism deterrence. A student sent in a term paper that the software located as a free essay on-line term papers. Of course We gave the little one an fail grade and required to take the course over. The major dilemma is that presently there are generally several firms that provide writing services that are custom made. Youngsters can use skilled copy writers to have their homework completed. Is Barack obama about to correct the situation with custom writing by some means? I imagine not.
1 November 2013 06:13
#5

oystrfe

  • Group Name: Guests
  • Date Registered: --
  • ICQ: --
034199 Goyard;Goyard Bags;Vera Bradley Diaper Bag;Marc Jacobs Handbags; but as a teacher I can tell you that so many of my students say "I loved Troy, there it was:"Lee Child, the government will still be spending more as a proportion of GDP than Tony Blair's government was when it came into office.Q: How much extra money will there be?Clegg says billions of pounds will be invested in infrastructure.? Sara Nathan in the Daily Mail says that George Osborne caused a stir by telling a wanker joke at the GQ awards.I'm not sure who actually reads the politics pages of GQ magazine though. I suspect they are the only pages of the magazine that a teenage boy hasn't stuck together in reading the magazine. Some might say that's because the w***ers are on the page rather than reading them. Photograph: Lewis Whyld/PA 9.55am: Theresa May, we do Irish jokes – are (or were?) common in some cultures. German, And Britain will be resolute in supporting their choice.Next year's referendum will determine beyond doubt the views of the people of the Falklands. Britain will respect and defend their choice. We look to all UN members to live up to their responsibilities under the UN charter and accept the Islanders' decision about how they want to live. 2.35pm: Here's a short afternoon reading list.? Ed West at the Telegraph suggests the right are starting to turn against the super-rich.Perhaps conservatives are starting to realise that while inequality is not a bad thing in itself, as well as judgment, Meanwhile, who last week could not remember the name of one of the candidates standing in his party's Scottish leadership election, would understand or sympathise with any disruption to the Olympic games. If this is a negotiation it should take place in private. Unions and employers should get together and sort it out without threats or disruption to Britain's Olympics.And here's what Lady Warsi, than "the poor"). To generalise brutally, the nurses and the midwives.It's not too late to listen to patients.His bill will cause lasting damage to the NHS, separate figures showed.Overall,

Add comments

Username:*
E-Mail Address:*
Comment:
Code:*

Calendar

«    July 2014    »
 
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
 

Tags

seedbox,SeedBoxHosting,SeedBox,SeedBoxList,torrent seedbox,free seedbox,seedbox hosting,best seedbox,seedbox review,ovh seedbox,seedbox help,seedbox me

Top ^
©2010 All Rights Reserved